General Questions

Mighty Nut, Chocmeister, and Bestie products were always made by Peanut Butter & Co., but some people found this confusing. We decided to bring everything under the Peanut Butter & Co. brand to make sure everyone knows who makes these delicious products.

We have changed our look, but our products are the same delicious Peanut Butter & Co. products you love! Due to changes in FDA guidelines for nutrition labeling standards, there have been minor changes to the language we use on our label to describe our ingredients, but none of the actual ingredients have changed.

You can purchase Peanut Butter & Co. products online on our website or from several online retailers including Amazon, Kroger, Vitacost, and Walmart. You can also find our products in-store at a variety of locations. Please use our Store Locator [link to store locator] to find the retailer closest to you!

We currently only ship from our website within the United States. However, while we don’t ship internationally, our products are available for purchase internationally. You can find our products online for purchase internationally at www.iHerb.com

We discontinued our PBCo Rewards program in February 2019. If you have earned 500, 1000, or 1500 points prior to February 2019, you will still be able to redeem those points for the coupon amount associated with the number of points you’ve earned. If you earned 500 points, the reward is a $5 coupon. If you earned 1000 points, the reward is a $10 coupon. If you earned 1500 points, the reward is a $15 coupon. You will be able to redeem your reward at any time by “spending” your points at checkout when you are logged in to your Peanut Butter & Co. account.

Please refer to the Shipping page on our website for accurate and up-to-date shipping information.

Since most of our products are food items, all sales are final, and we do not offer refunds or exchanges. In the event that your order does not arrive to your satisfaction, please contact us at customer.service@ilovepeanutbutter.com with your order number and any additional details and photographs.

Please contact customer service at customer.service@ilovepeanutbutter.com or call 1-866-LOVE-PB (1-866-456-8372)

Please contact customer service at customer.service@ilovepeanutbutter.com or call 1-866-LOVE-PB (1-866-456-6372)

Please contact customer service at customer.service@ilovepeanutbutter.com or call 1-866-I-LOVE-PB (1-866-456-6372